Lion's Den Club
The Perfect Bible
RenderUntoGod.org
Why Christians Should Reconsider Politics
Jesus never told His followers to share power with Caesar, but to render to God what belongs to God. The kingdom of God is not of this world — it's time to live like it.
Throughout history, Christians have often been drawn into political struggles, seeking to establish God's kingdom through earthly means. But Jesus consistently pointed His followers toward a different kind of kingdom — one that transforms hearts rather than governments. When we devote our primary energy to political battles, we risk obscuring the radical, counter-cultural message of the gospel.
What if our calling isn't to reform society through political power, but to demonstrate an alternative way of living that reflects God's priorities? By focusing on loving our neighbors, caring for the vulnerable, and embodying the values of heaven, we may accomplish far more than through partisan engagement. The early church changed the world not by seeking political influence but by living so distinctively that others couldn't help but notice.
The Teaching of Jesus: Render Unto Caesar
"Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's" - Mark 12:17 (KJV)
When Jesus spoke these famous words, His audience wasn't living in a democracy with voting rights – they were under an imperial dictatorship! Jesus wasn't giving campaign advice; He was making a profound distinction between earthly and divine authority.
This teaching challenges the common assumption that God's kingdom is advanced through earthly politics. Jesus wasn't encouraging His followers to seek political power, but rather to recognize the difference between what belongs to earthly rulers and what belongs exclusively to God – including our ultimate allegiance.
The Case Against Political Involvement
Throughout Scripture, we see God's sovereignty over earthly rulers. Daniel 2:21 reminds us that God "removes kings and sets up kings" according to His divine will. In Daniel 4, we witness Nebuchadnezzar himself learning this lesson through divine humbling, when he was reduced to living like an animal until he acknowledged that "the Most High rules in the kingdom of men, and gives it to whomever He chooses" (Daniel 4:25).
God Appoints Rulers
Even pagan kings like Nebuchadnezzar were called God's "servant" (Jeremiah 25:9).
Earthly Power Is Temporary
Daniel's visions show all human kingdoms ultimately giving way to God's kingdom.
God Controls Rulers' Hearts
"The king's heart is in the hand of the LORD" (Proverbs 21:1).
Our Kingdom Is Not Political
Christians serve a higher kingdom while living under earthly authorities.
If God establishes rulers according to His will, should Christians focus on political maneuvering? Or trust God's sovereignty while living as faithful witnesses?
The Case Against Political Involvement
Not of This World
Jesus clearly stated in John 18:36, "My kingdom is not of this world." Nowhere in Scripture did Jesus command political activism or civic rule for His followers. The early Christians were known for their radical love, not their political campaigns.
Political Idolatry
When we reshape our faith to fit our politics, we risk creating a god in our own image. Christians today often conflate patriotism with faith, diluting the radical message of Jesus with partisan loyalty.
Witness Through Love
The early church transformed the Roman Empire not through political power but through sacrificial love, care for the marginalized, and willingness to suffer rather than compromise their values.
Biblical Counterpoints: Must Christians Participate?
Old Testament Warnings
Scripture repeatedly cautions against trusting human rulers.
  • Israel rejected God by demanding a king (1 Samuel 8:6-7)
  • Political alliances represent spiritual compromise (Isaiah 31:1)
  • "Put not your trust in princes" (Psalm 146:3)
  • God alone establishes and removes rulers (Daniel 2:21, 4:25)
New Testament Kingdom
Jesus established a spiritual kingdom separate from worldly systems.
  • "My kingdom is not of this world" (John 18:36)
  • Satan offered political power as temptation (Matthew 4:8-10)
  • Our true citizenship is in heaven (Philippians 3:20)
  • Christians use spiritual, not "carnal" weapons (2 Corinthians 10:4)
Biblical Counterpoints: Must Christians Participate?
Duty to Select Leaders
Some say Christians should help choose godly leaders who support biblical values. They point to Joseph and Daniel who worked in government while keeping their faith.
Biblical Balance: Scripture reminds us, "Put not your trust in princes" (Psalm 146:3). While Joseph and Daniel served in government, they were placed there by God's hand, not through political campaigns.
Policy Impact on Values
Some believe politics affects issues like protecting life, supporting traditional marriage, and religious freedom. They think staying out of politics means giving up on these important fights.
Biblical Balance: Jesus never fought political battles to advance moral values. Instead, He taught that His followers should be "salt and light" (Matthew 5:13-16), changing culture through godly living, not political power.
Limited State Authority
Some think Jesus' words show that government power has limits. They feel Christians should be involved to make sure government stays within God's boundaries.
Biblical Balance: Paul teaches in Romans 13:1-7 that we should obey authorities, but Acts 5:29 reminds us to "obey God rather than men" when governments oppose God's commands. Our focus should be on faithful witness, not controlling government.
Tension in Scripture
The Bible shows a tension between being a citizen and being loyal to God's kingdom. This suggests Christians need to carefully balance both worlds without mixing them up.
Biblical Balance: Jesus clearly stated, "My kingdom is not of this world" (John 18:36). Our true citizenship is in heaven (Philippians 3:20), which should guide how we view earthly politics.
Church Leadership Model
In Acts 6:1-7, the apostles asked believers to choose seven deacons to serve. This shows Christians may have a role in picking leaders, though with spiritual guidelines rather than worldly politics.
Biblical Balance: This example applies to church leadership, not government. The early church focused on spreading the gospel and caring for others, not on changing Roman politics or laws.
Historical Practice of Christians and Politics
Early Church (1st-3rd Century)
Early believers generally abstained from seeking earthly power, often refusing military service or government positions that would compromise their faith. Their primary allegiance was to Christ's kingdom.
Christendom (4th-18th Century)
After Constantine, the church became intertwined with political power. This led to both good and bad outcomes, with many Christians questioning whether this alliance distorted the Gospel message.
Counter-Witnesses
Throughout history, movements like monasticism, the Anabaptists, and various renewal movements sought to recapture the early church's separation from worldly power and focus on Kingdom values.
Modern Examples: Faithful Dissent or Culture War?
Seven Mountain Mandate
This theology aims to capture seven cultural "mountains" including government. It redirects evangelical focus from salvation to dominion.
Dominion Theology
Teaches Christians must control governmental power. This view increasingly attracts young believers despite theological concerns.
Evangelical Mission
The Great Commission calls us to make disciples, not political victories. Our witness comes through love, not legislation.
These movements often replace the radical call of evangelism with political power-seeking. They transform the gospel into a platform for cultural dominance.
Living as Citizens of God's Kingdom
The Voting Dilemma
Christians often face difficult choices when figures like Donald Trump or Pierre Poilievre present platforms that partially align with some biblical values.
Kingdom First
Our primary allegiance must be to Christ's kingdom, not to political leaders like Charlie Kirk or JD Vance who claim to represent Christian values.
Faithful Witness
We engage politically as salt and light, evaluating the policies of figures like Trump or Poilievre by biblical standards, not partisan loyalty.
Christian nationalism dangerously conflates national identity with religious faith. Leaders who merge faith and nationalism, as seen with some followers of Trump and Kirk, often reduce the gospel to a platform for cultural power.
Jesus calls us to a different path—seeking first His kingdom while serving as faithful witnesses in our earthly citizenship, rather than placing our hope in political figures like Vance or Poilievre.
Modern Examples: Faithful Dissent or Culture War?
Christian Nationalism
The 21st century has seen increased debate over "taking back the culture" and Christian nationalism, highlighting the dangers of conflating faith with political power.
Alternative Witness
Many Christians choose to be peacemakers and advocates for the marginalized, prioritizing Gospel values over partisan politics.
Dominion Theology
Various branches of Dominion theology teach that Christians must control governmental power to establish God's kingdom on earth, raising concerns about biblical faithfulness and witness.
Church Focus
Some believers emphasize building strong local churches that model Kingdom values rather than seeking change through political channels.
Living as Citizens of God's Kingdom

Ultimate Allegiance to Christ
Place your identity in Christ above all earthly affiliations
Kingdom Values
Prioritize love, justice, mercy and truth over partisan loyalty
Active Witness
Demonstrate God's kingdom through service and community
Jesus calls His followers to reflect Him, not worldly powers. This means recognizing that the state is not God and never conflating patriotism with discipleship. When Christians place their ultimate hope in political victories, they risk compromising their witness to a different kind of kingdom.
Rather than striving for political influence, believers can focus on embodying Kingdom values in their families, churches, and communities. This witness speaks more powerfully than any political campaign.
Never Bite the Hand that Feeds
The tension between faith and politics remains unresolved for many Christians. Pastors rarely endorse specific parties because Kingdom priorities transcend partisan politics.
Church Independence
The church must maintain prophetic distance from government to speak truth to power when necessary.
Biblical Guidance
Scripture offers principles for citizenship but not specific voting instructions for modern democracies.
Faithful Witness
Christians serve best by modeling Christ's kingdom in community rather than seeking political power.
Balanced Engagement
Participate in civic life while remembering your ultimate citizenship belongs in God's kingdom.
Our calling is not to win cultural wars but to witness to a different kingdom. Render unto Caesar what belongs to Caesar, but reserve your heart for God alone.
Conclusion: What It Means to Render Unto God Today
Reexamine Political Engagement
Christians must rethink the necessity of voting or activism if it detracts from Christ's call. Not voting may sometimes be the most faithful choice when all options compromise core Gospel values.
Live Distinctively
Our challenge is to live so clearly for God's kingdom that earthly politics decrease in ultimate importance. When others see our priorities, they should notice something different about where we place our hope.
Embrace Radical Discipleship
Jesus invites us to a radical discipleship defined by allegiance to Him—not Caesar or party. This means being willing to stand against the political tide when Kingdom values demand it.
Remember, Jesus never commanded His followers to vote or engage in politics. While Christians may thoughtfully choose to participate in civic life, we must never make political engagement a requirement of faithful discipleship. Our primary citizenship is in heaven, and our ultimate hope lies not in earthly systems but in God's eternal kingdom.